How We Work
What Happens If I Don't Like My Custom Jewelry?
By Marc H. Merritt, GIA Diamonds Graduate · November 21, 2026
It's a fair worry. A custom piece is made only for you, so it can't simply go back on a shelf. The answer is to build approval into every step, so there are no surprises at the end. Here's how that works, and how to make sure your vision comes through.
Where you approve along the way
- The estimate. You get a written estimate before you pay anything, with no obligation.
- The stone. I send photos, video, details and the lab report for each option. You choose the stone, and where possible you see it in person or on video first.
- The CAD design. You receive a rendering with views from every angle and the dimensions. Ask for as many adjustments as you need at this stage. It's the most important approval: once you approve and production begins, changes carry a fee, and some may not be possible.
- The finished piece. In the New York tri-state area, you see it in person before paying the balance. Elsewhere, you approve it from photos and video.


What if the finished piece doesn't match the approved design?
If the piece differs from the design you approved, or there's a defect in materials or workmanship, we make it right. That's our responsibility, not yours.
What if I simply change my mind?
I'll be straightforward about this. Custom pieces are made to your specification and aren't returnable, except for a defect. Once the production deposit is paid, your stone is purchased and the piece is being made just for you, so that deposit isn't refundable. If you decide not to go ahead before that point, the $250 design and sourcing deposit isn't refunded, because it covers the sourcing and design work already done. All of this is in writing on How We Work and on your invoice.
Some changes are still possible after approval for a fee, such as adjusting a band width or the size. Ask me before assuming it can't be done.
How to get your vision across
- Send pictures of what you like, and what you don't. "Not this" is as useful as "this."
- Point to details. "I love the thin band on this one and the halo on that one" says more than a long description.
- Tell me about your daily life. If you work with your hands, play sports or wear gloves, that changes the setting.
- Share your budget range early. I'd rather design something you love within your budget than show you something you can't have.
- Check the size in real life. Ask me for the measurements in millimeters and compare them with a ring or pendant you already own.
- Take your time with the CAD. Don't approve a design you have doubts about. Ask your questions first.