← All articles

Buying Guide

Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Jewelry Designer

By Marc H. Merritt, GIA Diamonds Graduate · November 21, 2026

GIA Graduate Diamonds diploma awarded to Marc Howard Merritt, November 2018

A custom piece is a significant purchase. You're trusting someone with your money, your stone and sometimes your family history. These are the questions I'd ask any jeweler, including me, before handing over a deposit.

About the jeweler

  1. What training and credentials do you have? Look for gemological education from GIA or another respected school, and membership in trade organizations such as Jewelers of America, whose members follow a code of professional practices, and the Jewelers Board of Trade, the industry's credit and business-reporting organization. Be wary of vague claims like "certified jeweler" that don't say certified by whom.
  2. Can I see pieces you've made? Ask for photos of finished work, ideally next to the original CAD designs, so you can see that what was promised is what was delivered.
  3. What do other clients say? Read independent reviews, such as Google reviews, not only the testimonials on the jeweler's own site.
  4. Who actually makes the piece? Many fine jewelers design and source themselves and work with specialized manufacturers for casting and setting. That's normal. What matters is that one person is accountable from start to finish.

About the stone

  1. Does it come with a laboratory report, and from which lab? For diamonds and valuable gemstones, a report from GIA or another respected lab is your protection. Labs differ in how strictly they grade. Our Lab Reports Guide explains how.
  2. Is it natural or lab-grown, and has it been treated? Both should be disclosed in writing. Heating rubies and sapphires is common and accepted. Glass filling is a very different thing and must always be disclosed.
  3. Can I see the actual stone before I commit? In person, or at least on video, not just a stock photo.

About the process and the money

  1. Will I get a written estimate, and approve a CAD design before anything is made?
  2. What deposits are required, and what happens to them if I change my mind? Get the answer in writing before you pay.
  3. How long will it take? Ask for a timeframe for your specific piece.
  4. What if something is wrong with it? Ask how defects are handled and what the return policy is. Custom pieces generally aren't returnable, so the approval steps matter.
  5. How will it be delivered? It should be insured for its full value, with signature required.
  6. Who will appraise it? An appraisal from the seller is a conflict of interest. An independent appraiser is the better choice. See our Appraisals Guide.

Red flags

  • No written estimate, deposit terms or timeline.
  • Pressure to decide today, or a "special price" that disappears tomorrow.
  • A significant diamond or gemstone with no lab report, or a report from a lab you can't verify.
  • A price far below what comparable stones sell for. With gemstones, that usually means something wasn't disclosed.
  • An appraisal from the seller showing a value far above what you paid.
  • Payment instructions that change by email. Always confirm wire details by phone. A legitimate jeweler won't change wiring instructions by email.
  • Reluctance to show you the actual stone, or the finished piece before final payment.

How I answer these questions

I'm a GIA Diamonds Graduate (Graduate Diamonds diploma, 2018), a member of Jewelers of America and the Jewelers Board of Trade, and I founded MM Fine Jewelry and Gems Inc. in 2018. Most of my stones come with a report from GIA, IGI or another respected laboratory. You get a written estimate and approve a CAD design before anything is made. Deposits and terms are spelled out on How We Work, and appraisals go through independent appraisers. You can see finished pieces next to their CAD designs on our CAD Designs page, and read what clients say on our Reviews page. Ask me anything on this list.