← All articles

Custom Jewelry

Can I Use My Heirloom Gold or Stones in a New Piece?

By Marc H. Merritt, GIA Diamonds Graduate · November 21, 2026

Custom platinum wedding band with hand-engraved scrollwork, milgrain edges and a personal inscription inside

A grandmother's diamond, a parent's ring, a stone from a piece you no longer wear: giving family jewelry a new life is one of my favorite kinds of custom work. Here's what's possible, and what to know first.

Your stones: usually yes

Most heirloom stones can be reset in a new design. Diamonds, sapphires and rubies are durable and usually reset well. I examine every stone before agreeing to set it, because some need extra care or a different plan:

  • stones with chips, cracks or fractures reaching the surface, which can get worse under the pressure of setting;
  • softer or brittle gems, such as opal, emerald, tanzanite and pearl;
  • filled or clarity-enhanced stones, which can be damaged by heat or cleaning;
  • older cuts, such as old mine and old European cut diamonds, which may need a setting built around their proportions.

Before any work begins, your stone is weighed (when loose), measured, photographed under magnification and recorded on an intake receipt that we both sign. At the end, we check it against that record together. The details are in our policy for setting your own stone.

Your gold: talk to me first

Old gold has real value, but melting a family ring and recasting it isn't always the best choice. Older pieces are often a mix of karats and may contain solder from past repairs, which can affect the quality and color of a new casting. Fresh metal often gives a better result, and the original piece can stay in the family as it is. Every heirloom is different, so bring it to me and we'll decide together.

Keeping the story

  • Engrave a date, initials or a short message inside the band.
  • Echo a detail from the original, such as the milgrain, the engraving or the shape of the setting.
  • Divide a family's stones across several pieces, so each child or grandchild has one.
  • Keep the original setting if it's meaningful, and use the stone in something new.

Know what you have

Many family stones have never been graded. Before resetting a valuable stone, I recommend a laboratory report, and I can submit it to GIA through my own account (see GIA Reports). Afterward, an independent appraisal helps you insure the new piece properly. Please keep your own jewelry insurance in force while your stone is with us.

What it costs

Our standard $250 design and sourcing deposit applies and is credited to your piece. Setting a stone you supply carries a setting and handling fee, $250 minimum, quoted on your invoice. You can hand me your stone in person in the New York area, or ship it fully insured to our business address after contacting me first.